Nick & Toni's•East Hampton

Italian•$$$

Want to receive alerts for Nick & Toni's?

It is, in fact, not debatable that Nick & Toni's is the best restaurant on Long Island, a position at the front of the pack that has been hard-earned over a run of almost three decades and counting. Perhaps the most impressive thing about the East Hampton mainstay is that it feels as fresh as it ever has, leaning heavy on seasonally available ingredients and the deft touch of a Chef Joesph Realmuto, who understands the virtue of combining impeccable skill and casual restaurant. And since you asked, yes: that is Paul McCartney over there by the pizza oven.

Experiences at Nick & Toni's

Reservation
Indoors
It is, in fact, not debatable that Nick & Toni's is the best restaurant on Long Island, a position at the front of the pack that has been hard-earned over a run of almost three decades and counting. Perhaps the most impressive thing about the East Hampton mainstay is that it feels as fresh as it ever has, leaning heavy on seasonally available ingredients and the deft touch of a Chef Joesph Realmuto, who understands the virtue of combining impeccable skill and casual restaurant. And since you asked, yes: that is Paul McCartney over there by the pizza oven.
Reservation
Bar Seats
It is, in fact, not debatable that Nick & Toni's is the best restaurant on Long Island, a position at the front of the pack that has been hard-earned over a run of almost three decades and counting. Perhaps the most impressive thing about the East Hampton mainstay is that it feels as fresh as it ever has, leaning heavy on seasonally available ingredients and the deft touch of a Chef Joesph Realmuto, who understands the virtue of combining impeccable skill and casual restaurant. And since you asked, yes: that is Paul McCartney over there by the pizza oven.
Reservation
Bar High-Top
It is, in fact, not debatable that Nick & Toni's is the best restaurant on Long Island, a position at the front of the pack that has been hard-earned over a run of almost three decades and counting. Perhaps the most impressive thing about the East Hampton mainstay is that it feels as fresh as it ever has, leaning heavy on seasonally available ingredients and the deft touch of a Chef Joesph Realmuto, who understands the virtue of combining impeccable skill and casual restaurant. And since you asked, yes: that is Paul McCartney over there by the pizza oven.
Reservation
Standard Reservation
It is, in fact, not debatable that Nick & Toni's is the best restaurant on Long Island, a position at the front of the pack that has been hard-earned over a run of almost three decades and counting. Perhaps the most impressive thing about the East Hampton mainstay is that it feels as fresh as it ever has, leaning heavy on seasonally available ingredients and the deft touch of a Chef Joesph Realmuto, who understands the virtue of combining impeccable skill and casual restaurant. And since you asked, yes: that is Paul McCartney over there by the pizza oven.