Nick & Toni's

“Can I give the service and food 1 million stars? Our dinner was impeccable and the our server was so kind and attentive. I saw on the receipt his name is Moises. Thank you Moises for making our night so special. -zucchini chips - fish amazing - whipped ricotta”

“We really enjoyed the food there. Jessy was very helpful, recommending us drinks and food. Food was delicious. The stake was sooo good.”

“Had such a dreamy dinner at Nick & Toni’s 🍓✨ Everything was incredible, but the strawberry sorbet completely stole the show, made with Harris’s strawberries from California and you could actually taste the difference. Sweet, smooth, perfectly balanced, and honestly one of the best desserts I’ve had in a while. The staff was beyond attentive and gave amazing recommendations all night without ever feeling too much. The whole experience just felt warm, effortless, and so special. Already thinking about when I can go back again 😭🍝”

“Off season visit but the food and service was great. I could have eaten several servings of short rib ricotta ravioli they were so good, the homemade pasta was fantastic. The chocolate pecan tart was my favorite out of the two desserts we ordered, the tart itself and the ice cream went together perfectly. A hike for us to come up here but would definitely love to try other items on the menu.”

“I’ve been to Nick & Toni’s in East Hampton many times over the years, and it’s always a pleasant experience overall. The staff was kind enough to make our anniversary dinner feel special, which we really appreciated. The ambiance is lovely — warm, lively, and quintessential Hamptons — and the service is consistently attentive without being overbearing. That said, the food continues to leave me with mixed feelings. The appetizers were just okay this time around, nothing particularly memorable. The tilefish entrée was excellent — perfectly cooked and full of flavor — but the beef stew was a real miss. It was chewy, lacking depth, and tasted like it hadn’t been cooked long enough. Honestly, I make a better version at home. All in all, Nick & Toni’s remains a nice spot for a special occasion or a cozy evening out, but the food can be hit-or-miss, which keeps me from rating it higher.”