Milk Bar NYC

“Loved the cereal milk soft serve. The cornflakes on top were too rich for me, would skip that next time. Also love the compost cookie and the triple PB cookie is my fave. P.s. Mikey and Asher were an all-star team!! 🍪”

“If you know you know!! The desserts at Milk bar are amazing. They’re simple but unique and just everything I want in a dessert. I love their birthday cake truffles, and you can’t go wrong with any of the cookies. They also have cute boxes to package beautifully as a gift or you can even purchase a sturdy tin to reuse. If you’re up for ice cream, they have a cereal and milk ice cream that isn’t absolutely favorite- so much so I ordered it in the middle of winter! They also have a cute coffee bar inside of ice cream is not your thing.”

“All the deserts are crazy good. Maybe a little pricey, but well worth it… and I got a free cookie on my birthday. Horray!!! The PB crunch pie is insanely awesome!”

“After seeing many positive reviews, we stopped by Milk Bar and ordered the infamous Cereal Milk Soft Serve with Cornflake Crunch toppings. The serving size is definitely generous, however, we found both the ice cream and the topping to be surprisingly salty but wasn't necessarily a bad thing. The actual cereal milk flavor was quite mild. Personally, coming from Vancouver, we do prefer the cereal milk ice cream from Earnest! We also tried the Confetti Cookie and found it to be quite regular. The ice cream was definitely more of a standout item.”

“I'm not sure if I had too high expectation of this place towards my first time here, but I left somewhat disappointed. My husband and myself ordered the soft serve & cookie deal, and ordered a soft serve with a crunchy cornflakes topping, and the peanut butter cookie. The soft serve was quite plain, and the crunchy cornflakes that I heard so much about were basically just some clusters of Frosties cereal. The cookie was wayyy too sweet, although I expected its saltiness to balance the flavors, it didn't at all. We threw it awat after having 1 bite each. The only silver lining was the super kind staff that was welcoming & professional, but that's probably not a good enough reason to come back here..”