Old John's Luncheonette

“Perfect spot for a pre show dinner near the Lincoln center. The food is totally perfectly fine. The fries were actually above average!! The cocktails were above average too! I liked my frozen margarita x Aperol spritz thing. We could get a reservation day-of on a Wednesday night. They do not have gluten free bread. They have some gf dinner options but not a lot at the sub-$20 price range. I got an omelette.”

“During my NYC trip, I wanted to experience a classic diner and found Old John’s Luncheonette close to my hotel. It turned out to be a great choice! The food and atmosphere were great, but what really made the experience special was the service. Kathy was incredibly respectful and helpful regarding my halal diet. She took the time to make sure I had suitable options and made me feel completely comfortable. When I came back a second time, Kathy actually remembered my dietary restrictions — it was honestly mind-blowing. That kind of attention and care is rare. When they say “family-like environment,” they should mean this I believe. Customers greet each other, the staff call people by their names, and the whole place has such a warm and friendly vibe. It was a wonderful experience, and I’ll definitely be coming back next time I’m in NYC.”

“My partner and I walked in here around 10am on Sunday and were seated at the counter immediately. We ordered a couple of coffee’s and in classic diner fashion free refills! Our order was simple one breakfast burrito with chorizo and two eggs over easy with sourdough toast and turkey bacon. Both items hit the spot and weren’t overly expensive. This place gets busy so make sure to get in early. Also keep in mind that the hostess with queue waiting customers behind your seats at the bar which can be uncomfortable. I loved this spot and will certainly make an effort to stop again when I’m in the area.”

“Old John’s Luncheonette is such a classic New York gem. The moment you walk in, you get that cozy, old-school diner feel with a touch of modern charm. The menu has something for everyone whether you’re in the mood for a hearty breakfast, a burger, or a comfort-food favorite like the tuna melt (which is one of the best I’ve ever had). The service is warm and friendly, and you can tell this place has a lot of history and love behind it. Everything feels homemade and done with care. It’s the kind of spot you can come to before a show at Lincoln Center, grab brunch with friends, or just enjoy a relaxed meal on your own. Definitely one of those neighborhood staples that makes New York special.”

“I was quite surprised by the quality of this place. I enjoyed my meal so much. The short rib is great. I loved the service - very attentive and caring. I love the decor of the place - very nostalgic, yet modern. They have a lovely unsweetened iced tea that has a great taste - ugh I love tea!”