Madison Avenue Pizza

“This place won us over right away with Crown Apple on the menu — big plus! 🍏🥃 We went for the classic old-school pie 🍕 but couldn’t resist adding our own toppings. I loaded mine with mushrooms 🍄, onions 🧅, sausage 🌭, and black olives 🫒, while my husband went bold with pepperoni 🍖 and jalapeños 🌶️. Totally opposite tastes, yet we both loved it ❤️. The bake was right between his usual “extra crisp” 🔥 and my “just right” 👍, so it hit the perfect middle ground. The cheese sticks 🧀 were unique — my husband was a fan. He also raved about the fried ravioli 🍝✨, though that one wasn’t for me (fried food isn’t really my thing 🙅‍♀️). On the flip side, I absolutely loved the fresh salad 🥗 and homemade ranch 🥛🌿. Generous portions meant plenty of leftovers 🍽️, so dinner tonight is already sorted. Overall, a fun mix of flavors and a satisfying experience 😋.”

“This is the best pizza I have had in FLA; great char, excellent cheese, perfectly acidic sauce, and fantastic crunch. The wings were saucy, fresh, and crispy. We were extremely pleased and will return. It took us too long to try, but definitely a great stop.”

“Loved Maddison Avenue Pizza! The atmosphere and décor are great, and the staff is super friendly. Tons of creative pizza options, including cauliflower crust, which I really appreciated. It’s awesome that almost everything is made in-house, even the chicken nuggets. Everything tasted fresh and delicious. I’ll definitely be going back! 🍕😊”

“Madison Avenue Pizza easily serves up Tampa Bay’s best and most legit largest pizza. Every single thing here is made from scratch in-house: from the rich sauces to the perfectly chewy pizza dough, the fresh subs, hand-cut fries, juicy meatballs, and even their mozzarella sticks. You can taste the care and craftsmanship in every bite. Pull apart that stringy mozzarella stick. Bite into perfectly seasoned meatball parm sub. Enjoy their famous Five Boroughs wings that’s crispy, saucy, and packed with flavor. Pair them with one of their excellent cocktails, craft beers, or a cold draft for the perfect combo. That Old-School Cheese Pie has that genuine Brooklyn-style flavor. The service is consistently friendly, fast, and attentive, and the place itself is spotlessly clean with an awesome, welcoming vibe. If you want real pizza made with passion and quality, Madison Avenue Pizza is the spot.”

“You came for pizza? ”We’re out” says Madison Ave Pizza. Not once but twice in a month’s time our fairly large party arrived only to be told their 32” offering was “sold out”. This cluttered, dirty, and poorly staffed restaurant has ONE offering of interest, a giant pizza but NEVER has the ability to deliver. Their pizza is average at best but the biggest one touts a 12 lbs weight and over 11000 calories, an abnormal size to be sure. Just don’t count on getting one, they are ALWAYS sold out. The rest of the menu is a yawner…save your time and money and head to any one of the other great pizza places in Dunedin that have better food and don’t over promise and under deliver.”