Benny's Big Time Pizzeria

“Go for the food, stay for the vibes. Kellie was a top notch server & had such a welcoming, fun personality. Order the brussels caesar salad - you won't regret it.”

“Very clean up scale pizza....Lots of homemade delicious items to order off the menu. They also have a pastry chef with homemade daily desserts. Two of us ate after walking the Greenfield lake trail. Total cost with 3 beers, two uniquely different side salads and one 10 inch pizza we created for around $70.00. Great location and a fun atmosphere....”

“This South Front Street pizzeria is a wow. Check the menu daily. If they run out of an ingredient they change up what they make. If they get something new...same. I recommend the pizza...pick one and work your way around. This place hops so get there early or prepare to wait. Update: consistency is becoming a challenge. the center of my last order was soupy and almost raw. previously, it was suggested I order it well done. it was on one side. it wasn't turned. Dress warmly, heat really isn't a thing here”

“Opted to share 3 appetizers, chicken parm bites, garlic "knots," and brussel sprouts. The brussel sprouts were probably the least interesting of the three with more sauce than necessary and an unpleasant bitternness. The garlic "knots" were very unique with no knot in sight, more like fried dough ball. The chicken parm bites with hot honey were especially unique and tasty!”

“Came here after a very good day, a lot of things are starting to go better in my life finally for the first time since March 30th 2026 accident. I brought my family here after some nice lady at the Peak Taproom and Kitchen in Surf City,NC mentioned coming here. I've been meaning to make the trip down so I did, I loaded up the family in the Tesla Therapy Toaster and let Elon drive us down there, he drove around the building I believe what I counted 4 times before I decided to park since people started looking. I planned ahead and had a reservation, they gave me the nicest table in the place, the big round one in the corner. The family sat down and Becca greated us. We looked over the menu and ordered. We wanted a little while for the pizza and pasta to come. Soda was provided via cans and I asked for a glass and Becca hooked me up. The water that provided wad probably the best water I've had at a restaurant in a long time. Food came and was good, not amazing but good. I'll definitely come back. Maybe it's because I just had pizza like 6hrs prior so idk. Becca did say Wendsday is New York style so let's see if they give Vittos a run for their money. All in all I give this a solid 4 stars out of 5. Let's see if that changes the next time I come which will be soon. That sugar buzzed place next door was great! Let's see what pizza place I try next, maybe Domino's 🤔 I couldn't get a picture of the toaster in front of Benny's Big Time Pizzeria because of all the construction, maybe that's what Elon got confused and drove us in circles for 10min and almost missed my reservation time. Thanks Elon...”