Super Nice Pizza

“Best pancakes in the UWS. Got the chorizo breakfast pizza and burger and also wonderful. Can’t wait to try the dinner menu. Staff was welcoming, food came quick, and everything was delicious. Highly recommend”

“We love Super Nice Pizza! We’ve been coming here regularly since they opened in 2025 and they never miss. We’ve love the pizzas (pepperoni is our favorite) but they are always changing up their menu and keeping things updated! They recently started brunch and the hits keep coming! Get the pancakes and the breakfast burritos! The staff has always been so accommodating when we bring our 10mo baby and always so warm and welcoming!”

“Amazing addition to the neighborhood! This place feels cozy and neighborhoody. Our waiter was professional, friendly, and personable :) Service was super quick. Smoky potato pizza was GREAT, with the tomato and olive pizza coming in second. Caesar salad was divine (not drenched in dressing — important!) and came in a fun sharing portion. Would be great if they had pizza knives. Coming back soon!!”

“I’ve walked past this place countless times and finally stopped in and i am glad I did. Arrived around 6:30 PM on a Saturday with no reservation and were seated immediately. Service was fast and friendly, and the vibe is great: dim, lively, and a bit loud in a good way. We shared the sausage and elote pies. The crust/undercarriage is the real standout, seriously phenomenal. The elote pie is a must-order. The sausage pie, though, fell a bit flat; I could barely taste the sauce or cheese. Overall: fresh, vibrant food and a great atmosphere. I’ll definitely be back—especially to try the short rib burger.”

“👍👍 Thumbs up! Came in expecting pizza, but the **brisket short rib burger** completely stole the show. So good I came back *twice in the same week*. Perfectly cooked, juicy, and served with a huge portion of fries. **Pro tip:** Ask for the burger off the *secret menu* — it takes it to another level. Don’t skip the **calamari + cherry pepper appetizer**. They’re good separately, but amazing when eaten together in one bite. The **espresso martini** was smooth and well-balanced. Owner is hands-on and checks in on tables, which is always a nice touch. They also have a **rewards program** and offer a **birthday discount** (make sure your server scans your QR code before paying). Great spot for date night, friends, or family dinner. Would definitely return.”