Johnny Pepperoni

“I rated “service” and “atmosphere” as 5 starts b/c was delivery from grub hub. Square pizza with sausage, mushroom, onion was great! Just like my Italian wife’s grandma (nonna) used to make.”

“Johnny pepperonis is the BEST!!! We have been many times for dinner and takeout and their pizza is amazing! I decided to do an Italian theme for my bridesmaid proposal and knew I had to host it at Johnny Pepps and I’m SO glad I did. The service, food, and vibes were amazing and we had the best night! The staff was so friendly and accommodating and went above and beyond to make the night special for us!! I highly recommend hosting your next dinner party at Johnny Pepperonis. Thank you so so much for an incredible evening!!”

“Honestly, love Johnny pepperonis and the food is fantastic however the prices are absolutely outrageous for the quantity of food that you receive. You are better off going down the street to Napolis for 1/2 the price. Pic attached- one chicken cutlet for $35.. delicious but that’s actually insane. I have been coming here for awhile and this was the smallest amount of food I’ve ever recieved.”

“Ordered a “large” 16-inch margherita with pepperoni and it ended up being closer to 15 inches Agree with other reviewers about a mismatch between price and quality/quantity of what you recieve. Paying $30 for the pizza plus $6 for pepperoni would’ve been fine if the topping wasn’t so sparse. It tasted decent, just hard to justify the cost (~$49 all said and done for delivery ☹️)”

“I rarely leave food reviews but I had a pickup order here recently which really bothered me. First of all, Johnny Pepperoni is not cheap ($31 for their namesake pepperoni cheese pizza, and $15 for the most mediocre Caesar salad - more on this below). For $31 before tax tip and any delivery fee (I picked up), a pepperoni pizza better be good. This pizza was solid, cheese was good, crust is just ok. The most annoying thing was paying $6 to add pepperoni and only receiving 15 or so slices. When pepperoni is in your name, and I pay $6 on top of a $25 pizza to add it, you better back it up with some volume. I felt like Johnny pepperoni certainly did not show me the pepperoni. I could not recommend NOT ordering the Caesar salad enough. This was the most frustrating item - $15 for some old bad lettuce, cheese and croutons. To give them credit, their Caesar dressing is good. I would pay $5 for this salad and not $15 when you can get a very very good Caesar from Alfalfa which is like 5 blocks away. This one felt like a complete rip off. Mozzarella sticks are good but again, you’re paying $3 per mozzarella stick. Also the marinara sauce that comes with the sticks is way too chunky and hard to dip with. I paid around $65 to pickup a pepperoni pizza, mozzarella sticks, and Caesar salad. I will not be coming here again unless the prices or menu are changed, and I knew that about 5 minutes after sitting down to eat.”