RP Prime

“We recently hosted our baby shower at RP Prime Steakhouse, and the experience exceeded our expectations. The private room was beautiful, with excellent lighting and a perfect setup for our event. The staff was outstanding throughout the entire process, incredibly accommodating, attentive, and always willing to help with anything we needed. The food was exceptional, and the atmosphere was warm, elegant, and welcoming. Everything came together perfectly and helped make our celebration even more special. Thank you to RP Prime Mahwah for making such an important day for our family truly memorable. We highly recommend it for special events and gatherings”

“This place is great. Very high end atmosphere but not too expensive. The staff is amazing too with balancing being attentive but not intrusive. The food was amazing. I was there with a party so luckily I was able to taste alot of stuff during my visit. I apologize some of the photos were after alot was missing from the platters but you can get the picture They started us with lobster and shrimp platters. I dont think I've ever had such huge shrimp before. The lobster and shrimp were both cooked perfectly. They also brought out bacon steak which was amazing. For starters we also had some crab cakes. Portobello ravioli with trufle sauce. Calamari and fried cauliflower. For the main i had a ribeye with sautéed mushrooms as well as some Brussels sprouts with crispy bacon. Everything came out fairly quickly for a busy Friday night. Everything was cooked to perfection and seasoned well so I didn't even have to ask for any salt or pepper. Highly recommend!!!”

“If you're looking for a quality, NYC worthy steakhouse, look no further. I've been here for lunch and dinner and both times offer a terrific and delicious experience. Waiters are attentive without being overbearing. The menu has a slew of fun appetizer options. The seafood tower was filled with fresh clams, oysters, shrimp, and lobster. The sushi was great. The prime rib sandwich hit the spot at lunch. The star of the restaurant is obviously the steaks and they dont disappoint. Sides are shareable and great. Its not an inexpensive experience but the overall experience is worth it. If you want to feel like you're at a New York City steakhouse without the commute into NY.... this is your new favorite spot.”

“This spot offers super convenient valet parking and a modern, inviting vibe that definitely beats the Fair Lawn branch. Plus, the food is consistently savory and delicious. The only thing I would say it too a little to long for the entrees to come out. We did have appetizers but took almost 1hr after that to get entrees. The service was phenomenal.”

“Food: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ We were offered a complementary Caesar's salad with gorgonzola cheese which hit the sweet spot! We ordered the surf & turf along with the Dry aged filet mignon butcher's cut along with truffle Mac n cheese and mashed potatoes accompanied with regular coffee. The filet mignon had a good crust& was seasoned well. I asked for medium and was satisfied initially, however as I cut deeper I observed parts of it was cooked unevenly medium-medium rare-rare. I wasn't offended but for the price, you've got to live up to it. The surf & turf was outstanding. Truffle Mac n cheese didn't have a crispy crust, but was tasty. The mashed potatoes weren't garnished with any greens, but was tasty. I wish there was bone marrow to go along with the steaks. Service:⭐⭐⭐ We were greeted & seated pomtly by the maître d', however we were seated on a table that had no tableware or napkins. Ryan was our waiter and treated us very well, however even he didn't observe that we were seated on an unprepared table. The table cloth had stains in several places which seemed unsanitary and uncomfortable to eat on. Upon asking for the napkins Ryan provided them to us promptly, however they were stained as well. The coffee cup seemed like it wasn't washed thoroughly as it had some debris on the outside. We didn't say anything so we could finish our experience for an honest review. Nothing against Ryan or the Maître D'. Atmosphere: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ The location was great, we sat outside in. 72⁰ temp and it was pleasant. Outdoor dining area was better than the indoor with nice string lights and pleasant to the eye colors. The bathrooms were clean and good looking. I'm sure they have a good music playlist, I wish I heard something. Overall: 4.1⭐s Recommendations: For the price, y'all need to up the game with cleanliness, garnished food, and accurate temp of the food. All employees are kind and welcoming, however need to be more vigilant of the tables and seating guests.”