New York Prime

“Our experience was absolutely amazing! Lucas was our server and he was very knowledgeable about every item on the menu. We will definitely be back strictly because of Lucas and how great his service was! The food was very good too. It’s expensive but it’s very delish! I just want to put emphasis on how GREAT Lucas was. We left him 100$ tip on 258 tab! Ask for Lucas! He made our experience a thousand times better and it is by far probably the best server there! Ask for Lucas! :)”

“Came here for a friend's bjrthday dinner. If you come in a good-sized group, they'll advise you to place your entire order at the beginning, so they can pace out your offerings. I had the baked shrimp to start. The jumbo shrimp were great, but I do feel they could serve you an additional one to two more than they do, for the price. For an entree, I had the steak delmonico with Cajun butter on top, which was excellent. The outer char was done to perfection. For sides, I ordered the loaded baked potato & the broccolini. For a drink, I ordered the Paper Plane, which was also excellently made. It was so much food that I took half of my meal home to enjoy the next day. Service was excellent from start to finish. If you self park in the adjacent deck, they'll also validate your parking to make parking free. I would return again.”

“If you are looking for the best steakhouse in Atlanta for a professional gathering, New York Prime remains the undisputed heavyweight champion. We recently hosted a business dinner here with colleagues, and the experience was nothing short of flawless from start to finish. Why It’s Perfect for Business The atmosphere strikes that rare balance between high-energy sophistication and a polished, professional environment. It’s the kind of place where deals get done over world-class service. • The Food: The USDA Prime steaks are aged to perfection and served on sizzling plates. The Pittsburgh char on the bone-in ribeye is legendary, and the "colossal" shrimp cocktail actually lives up to its name. • The Service: The staff operates with a level of precision you rarely see. They are attentive without being intrusive—ideal for maintaining the flow of a business conversation. • The Ambiance: With live piano music and a classic, upscale interior, it feels timeless and impressive. Standout Recommendations • Must-Order: The Haggerty hash browns and the thick-cut sizzling bacon. • For the Table: Don't skip the butter cake for dessert; it’s a guaranteed crowd-pleaser for the team. New York Prime isn't just a meal; it's a high-end experience that reflects perfectly on anyone hosting a professional event. Whether you’re a local or visiting Atlanta for a conference, this is the premier destination for top-tier dining and prime cuts.”

“Great atmosphere. We went on Valentine’s Day weekend & the wait was a little longer. The food came hot and taste great. We would come back. The waiter was amazing. Oysters - 5/5 less salt on the plate under the oysters Crab cake - 5/5 I would have liked more sauce”

“New Your Prime delivered an amazing dining experience from start to finish. Every dish was cooked to perfection and full of flavor. The crab cake was fresh and delicious, the baked shrimp was seasoned just right, and the lamb chops were tender and juicy. The Scottish salmon was perfectly cooked, and the shrimp Alfredo was rich, creamy, and absolutely satisfying. The sides were just as impressive — the Brussels sprouts were flavorful, and the cheese mashed potatoes were smooth, creamy, and packed with comfort. Great food, great quality, and a restaurant that clearly takes pride in what they serve. Highly recommend and definitely returning!”