Rachel's Restaurant & Bakery

“Amazing food ,very cozy and comfy place ! Our waitress Sherry was brilliant. Super funny and very friendly! That same day we went back for a dinner and we meet Captain Ron . Omg , he was beyond friendly and welcoming and he is a super star of that place . Service was amazing! On your visit to FI Ocean beach you MUST visit. Defenetly recommend this place ! What an unique experience!”

“Delicious food. The best on fire island and an amazing restaurant for New York in general. The restaurant is mostly family run. All staff are extremely kind. Very helpful in accommodating dietary restrictions as well. The food tastes amazing, clean, and healthy. Great quality. I get food from there at least daily when in ocean beach. The gelato is also amazing. The dine in service is a little slow but still great. Highly recommend this restaurant. My pictures are only from my takeout order. You must have the Flounder sandwich and the chocolate hazelnut ice cream.”

“Such a good burger!!! Was very hangry since it was 6pm and i hadn't eaten lunch and this tasted amazing!! Was so full afterwards. The staff was friendly and attentive. The ambience was chill and not as busy compared to other places!! Highly recommend!!”

“We were looking for a great brunch spot in Fire Island and were pleasantly surprised with what Rachael has to offer. Hands-down the best bloody Mary’s on the island. Our kids loved the oatmeal and the French toast (even if the French toast for the kids size was too small). We went on a holiday weekend and the wait wasn’t too bad either. It would be great if they had more outdoor seating but The food was very good and worthwhile spot for breakfast or brunch. Will definitely be back.”

“Very nice and quaint spot for breakfast or lunch. We had the country egg sandwich and 2 egg platter, both were delicious, especially the potatoes, those really stood out! The boozy iced coffee needed a little simple syrup but that's a matter of preference. The service was courteous and quick. Will definitely be back and I'd recommend it.”