Island Way Grill

“We just had our wedding here in March 2026 and i cannot say enough good things about it! Our day was absolutely perfect thanks to Amber and her team! The room was beautiful and exactly how we wanted it to be, the staff was friendly and attentive, and the food was DELICIOUS. All of our guests couldn’t stop complimenting how good the food and service was! Thank you so much for making our day so special”

“Absolutely fantastic! I haven’t had this level of exceptional service since prior to COVID. We came here for my birthday dinner and in our party it was my son, my husband and I. Prior to dinner we enjoyed the amazing happy hour! Then we moved to our table outside and enjoyed sushi and oysters on the half shell, all of which was delicious! We had Jonas as our server and he was absolutely exceptional! He was so sweet and gave my son a colorful pen since our little guy didn’t get crayons with his kids menu (which was a non-issue anyway). Jonas had made the wonderful recommendation of the Hog Fish with the Macadamia Crust, I had initially been eyeing something else on the menu but I’m thankful I went with his suggestion. My husband had the snapper and he was equally happy! We had the amazing Crème Brûlée which had a perfect top and done just right and we also enjoyed the apple dumpling! Jonas worked hard to keep us warm with the heaters and was hauling gas tanks and lighting the heaters to keep us and everyone else warm. He worked so hard to make it a wonderful experience, while also working hard to make others experiences equally great. There are not many young people who are willing to “serve,” have an a service heart or go the extra mile today and Jonas is truly the exception. So many could learn from him! We come from Wisconsin every year and will definitely be making this a priority stop again for exceptional food and service! Thank you for making my birthday special Jonas and Island Way Grill!”

“Fantastic food and a great atmosphere and the staff are eager to please. Definately something special if you are having an event or a special someone to enjoy it with. Even thought it is busy it still seems to allow for your group to chat and enjoy the time. There is free valet service and a free parking area but the real star if the show is the food. There is also an oyster and sushi batlr that have some incredible flavours that are definately worth the trip.”

“Enjoyed a lovely meal here with excellent service. My salmon was fabulous but my husband’s hogfish was very thin so not filling, unfortunately. Our friends’ meals had generous portions. A/C in main dining room wasn’t working well so anyone inclined to get hot, was sweating. I was ok but just mentioning because it was surprisingly warm.”

“Tried the Supper Club (early bird) menu for $25. Highlights were the phenomenal service (Amanda) and the Caesar Salad. Surf and Turf and Fishermans platter were pretty good. Dessert was an over baked brownie. (Please quality check before serving.) In the end it’s a great deal and you easily get what you pay for.”