Benny's Coastal Kitchen

“Benny's seems to be a modern take on Fishcamp. The service was wonderful and the cocktail menu so much fun. Our food was delicious except I would pass on the overly large Hush Puppies, there's better around the island. We sat outside and loved the ambiance”

“We had a wonderful meal here this week. Food was excellent with small tapas plates that we shared as we were on the rooftop restaurant 41&UP. We had a brand new server and he was awesome! Beautiful view at sunset! Perfect vibe for a night out with grownups. Tip: If you are looking for their fabulous hush puppies at 41 then you need to order them downstairs to go and bring them up as they are not on the upstairs menu. Great suggestion from the server but they should just add them to the upstairs menu.”

“Benny’s Coastal Kitchen is just a really fun place to hang out. The atmosphere is what stands out right away! It’s got a relaxed, beachy vibe that makes it easy to kick back and enjoy yourself. The food was great without being over the top. We had the special Mahi Mahi and the Fried Whole Fish, and both were really good and hit the spot. Overall, it’s one of those places you go for the experience just as much as the food, and it does both really well.”

“Time for an updated review! Tonight we had Audra for a Server, and she was incredible ! Fun, knowledgeable, professional, and kind! My husband had the Stew and stated it was the best seafood he has had! I loved the Mahi special as it was perfectly cooked, and came out hot and looking like a piece of art ! Drinks were so good but my favorite was the artichoke appetizer!!! We made another reservation before we left with Diana who was beyond NICE!! Highly recommend this restaurant! A favorite for sure.”

“Dude, Benny's Coastal Kitchen is a pretty solid spot to wash up at after a long day on the beach. The atmosphere and vibe were totally on point, the kind of place where you feel relaxed the moment you walk in. They even take reservations which is super convenient and honestly a nice touch for a spot with that kind of upscale feel. Waters stayed topped off all night which kept the good vibes flowing. The seafood towers looked absolutely epic and compared to other places we have hit up they were a great value. Hush puppies were solid and the sides all around were on point. Most of the crew at our table were stoked on their meals so that is always a good sign. Now I have to keep it real, the rice next to me was almost crunchy which was a bit of a bummer, and my grouper was a little tough and did not have much flavor going on which was a bummer for a coastal spot. You kind of expect the fish to be the star of the show you know? BUT the key lime cheesecake, oh man, that thing was absolutely insane. Worth every bite and then some. Overall not a bad landing spot at all, just wish the fish had matched the rest of the experience. Still a good hang though and worth checking out!”