The Brotherhood of Thieves

“Had a Wonderful Very Fresh and Refreshing Heirloom Burrata Salad with Fresh Basil and Yummy Balsamic Pearls at the Brotherhood Will be eating plenty more of these Delicious Salads this Summer!”

“The Brotherhood of Thieves is a Nantucket classic and a restaurant we found ourselves returning to twice during our visit. While wait times can vary depending on the season, reservations are highly recommended year-round if you want to avoid a long wait. The food was consistently top-notch, with a menu that offers something for everyone in a warm and welcoming atmosphere. Every meal we had was excellent, but the true standout was the carrot cake. It was so good that it became the reason we came back for a second visit! Moist, flavorful, and generously portioned, it’s easily one of the best desserts we’ve had on the island. Whether you’re visiting Nantucket for the first time or are a longtime fan of the island, Brotherhood of Thieves is well worth adding to your dining list. Great food, friendly service, and a memorable dessert make it a place you’ll want to return to again and again.”

“Boom boom shrimp was incredible, and then we ended with the spicy rigatoni. 10/10 delish and the staff was so friendly and fast. Stumbled into this place by accident, but it was def kismet. Tysm!! Xo”

“Coming up to Nantucket for a wedding and a post Halloween windstorm delayed our ferry quite substantially giving us a choice: Walk into the wedding ceremony 20 minutes late looking like a pair of southern drifters or grab a bite and a beer at Brotherhood of Thieves. We made the right choice! Walking into this 1700s whaling bar felt made us feel like we were headed in for a celebratory boozing binge after taking down Moby Dick 🐳 The food and ambiance were awesome but Brooke really made this place shine, she was phenomenal. We will be back!!!”

“Nantucket Mass. We sat at the upstairs bar for lunch. For drinks: Old fashioned with Basil Hayden and a Grey Lady Ale for the hubby. For lunch: I had the chicken cobb salad (no blue cheese) and the hubby had the buttermilk chicken sandwich with fries. Both entrees were very yummy. We both ate every late bite of our lunches. Service was good but not so attentive. Bathrooms were clean.”