The Tewksbury Inn

“Great food and cozy vibes! We had a wonderful Saturday night here with friends. The ambience is rustic and cozy, though it gets very busy—the parking lot was packed! Our waiter, Joe, was fantastic and provided above-and-beyond service. The Salmon Tartare and Yellowfin Tuna (try it with the forbidden rice) were outstanding. The winter salad was also a hit. Unfortunately, the NY strip was slightly burnt, but the Crème Brûlée and perfect coffee ended the night on a high note. A solid find in Oldwick!”

“Had a lovely meal at the Tewksbury Inn with friends last night. We got seated immediately even though we were early. The little room upstairs where we sat was nice and quiet. Cocktails were very good and all of our food was excellent. The pork chop was the table favorite. We sat at our table for a very long time catching up and were never rushed out the door. 5* all the way. Thank you.”

“Went for a casual meal with relatives. For a Saturday night it was busy as you would expect. But the service was attentive. I had the french onion soup which was perfect. Then I had the steak frites. Well portioned and served to my liking. Demi Sauce gave it a nice extra flavor. Wine selections are abundant. Dessert menu is small, but all are well prepared. When in the country, stop in for a great meal.”

“This gem came well recommended for lunch. We ordered a grilled chicken sandwich, chicken burger, and yellowfin tuna wrap which came with fries. The food was above average in flavor and presentation. The tuna was flavorful but I found the wrap to be a bit dry. Nevertheless, the staff were extremely cordial. The restaurant was rather busy with it being a Thursday lunch. I recommend making reservations to ensure a table. I'd love to return to try the dinner menu.”

“I give two stars because the server tried hard. And someone in the kitchen gave great plate presentation. This place used to used to be the best. It's mediocre at best. Our server was delightful. Best part of the meal. But she was stressed, and one of maybe two servers on the floor. The place needs a deep, deep cleaning. I get it, it's an old place, but even old restaurants should and can be cleaned. Even outside, needed cleaning. The meal started with an iced tea, that was sent back because it was bad/sour. Onion rings with more like strings and fried in some sort of dirty low quality oil. Same with the fried chicken sandwich I had. Sitting here with an upset stomach and a headache from what we had, it's disappointing! Skip it, you are better off eating at home.”