Il Pizzaiolo-Warrendale

“Saw the review below me and the name and why am I not the least bit surprised it’s Rob and Terisa complaining yet again about a bartender or server! Maybe you two are the issue? Look at your negative reviews you leave everywhere you go. I wonder if AstraZeneca knows how their regional director, Rob Sharlow, speaks to people he thinks are beneath him? Service at il pizzaiolo in the restaurant and bar is always wonderful anytime we go in! Don’t let one bad review ruin it for you. People just like to complain and want to be heard because no one else cares about them!”

“The food was amazing! The service par excellence! The atmosphere was warm and inviting if a little loud. The stuffed banana peppers were the best I've ever had. Warning, the escarole beans and sausage is moderately hot (spicy.) The shrimp and lobster scampi was very good, but piece de resistance was the papperdelle alla funghi. Literally the most savory, flavorful pasta dish I have ever tasted. Highly recommend.”

“I thought the food ( Il ragu) and drinks (espresso and pistachio martini) were very good. I think for an Italian restaurant thats not a huge chain, the food was good. This is a good restaurant for date night.”

“I have eaten here relatively frequently. The food is excellent, and the service is also great. The staff is knowledgeable about the menu, making suggestions, and also offers great wine pairing recommendations. I'm more of a white wine drinker, and I love their Moscato. My favorite go-to dishes are the Chicken Marsala, Lasagna, and if I'm looking for something more laid-back, all their pizzas are wonderful. They also have a great patio of you like sitting outside. I would recommend booking a reservation if your looking at Thursday through the weekend as they are generally pretty busy. But if your looking for a good Italian Resturant with a great feel, I highly recommend Il Pizzaiolo-Warrendale.”

“I had a decent experience overall //The pizza is a bit of a mixed bag—some options are really good, while others are just average and probably not the best choice on the menu.--- it’s a great spot for hanging out. The vibe is excellent, and the service was friendly and attentive. It’s a solid place for a drink and a nice atmosphere (been there on June 2025)”