Oldestone Steakhouse

“The interior was stunning and the food was of the quality expected in this price range. The presentation was also very nice, what really stood out was the service from being greeted at the front desk to the farewell. Our server Freddy C was so very attentive yet not intrusive, I would say perfect.”

“Let me start out by saying I gave four stars for food only because I didn’t have any. But I hope to someday soon try and I will alter my rating based upon that experience. Oldestone Steakhouse is a transformed church, and simply spectacular on the inside. My girlfriend’s and I sat at the bar and we each had a specialty cocktail. I asked the bartender to make my espresso martini with tequila, as I often do prefer it served that way. My drink was incredible, in fact, even my girlfriends enjoyed their drinks thoroughly. I also think it’s worth mentioning, the glassware that our drinks were served in, I appreciate the quality of the stemware exponentially! My girlfriend drinks, sport, garnished, beautifully, service at the bar with spectacular, and we enjoyed having conversation with the manager as well! I look forward to returning one day, sitting at a table (after my bar cocktail, of course), and indulging in a big fat juicy steak!”

“We visited on Saturday for my birthday. Terrific atmosphere and delicious food. The sweet potato souflee was spectacular! Loved all the stained glass windows and the huge painting (we ate in the dining room upstairs) Service was spectacular. Can’t wait to visit again! Thanks for the great experience.”

“We visited Olde Stone Steakhouse for the first time on New Year’s Eve with very high expectations, given how often it’s recommended. The upstairs dining room is absolutely beautiful—being in a former church makes the atmosphere one of the best parts of the experience. Service was great throughout the night, and both the Caesar salad and wedge salad were standouts, with the Caesar being one of the best things we had. Unfortunately, the porterhouse for two didn’t live up to the hype, especially for the price. While it was cooked well, it lacked flavor and relied heavily on sauces. Midway through dinner, we could feel vibrations from a DJ downstairs, which was distracting for what’s meant to be a high-end dining experience. Dessert was solid but not memorable. Overall, the vibe and service were excellent, but the food didn’t justify the cost”

“Tried this restaurant for valentines day atmosphere seemed very chaotic even for valentines day. Upstairs was gorgeous loved how they transformed this church into a dining room. However there definitely is a disconnect between the 'front' and 'back' of the house. Dan our waiter was friendly, very helpful and knowledgeable who, unfortunately, had no support from the kitchen and seemed like he was catching complaints all night because of it. Lollipop lamp chops were good but not memorable. Filet mignon was not cooked to request. Asked for medium rare and got well done. My date ordered duck which the breast was over cooked, and somehow cold. The truffle fries were good but seemed more like bar fries than what you'd expect at a fine dining restaurant. Finally the drinks. I ordered a gin gimlet which was poorly mixed. My date and I both thought it might have been the gin we requested. Tried a vodka gimlet and had the same issue. However, I came home and made one with the same gin and immediately realized the bartender either did not shake it, or didnt use crushed ice, or both. This restaurant was not what I expected from a New Hope fine dining restaurant. They have a lot to fix to be on par with Stella and Odette's especially for the price!”