The Best Italian Restaurants in New York
Updated September 2026 · 327 places tracked
New York has 327 Italian restaurants on WaitlistWizard's live reservation catalog, clustered in West Village, Williamsburg, and Greenwich Village. The list below ranks the standouts by diner rating, and we track real-time table availability at 245 of them.
Osteria la Baia
Italian · Midtown · $
4.9(7,074)Macoletta Brick Oven Pizzeria
Italian · Astoria · $
4.9(4,316)Osteria Carlina Tribeca
Italian · Tribeca · $
4.9(1,055)Macoletta - Williamsburg
Italian · Williamsburg · $$
4.9(803)Aromi
Italian · Carrol Garden · $$
4.9(788)Bar Madonna
Italian · Williamsburg · $$
4.9(203)CICCIO Cincin
Italian · West Village · $$
4.9(81)La Pecora Bianca Bryant Park
Italian · New York · $$
4.8(7,955)La Pecora Bianca - SoHo
Italian · New York · $$
4.8(7,148)Osteria Nonnino
Italian · New York · $$$
4.8(4,706)Da Andrea - Chelsea
Italian · New York · $$$
4.8(2,103)Lucciola
Italian · Upper West Side · $$$
4.8(1,562)Bar Mario
Italian · Red Hook · $$
4.8(495)Da Adriano
Italian · Lenox Hill · $
4.8(350)Rosticceria Evelina
Italian · Fort Greene · $$
4.8(224)Osteria by Primo
Italian · Staten Island · $
4.8(186)Olio e Più– Greenwich Village
Italian · New York · $$$
4.7(11,808)La Pecora Bianca - NoMad
Italian · New York · $$$
4.7(6,730)Osteria Barocca Little Italy
Italian · Little Italy , soho, financial district ,noho, east village . · $
4.7(3,398)Chazz Palminteri Italian Restaurant
Italian · Midtown · $$
4.7(2,205)Nizza
Italian · Hell's Kitchen · $$
4.7(2,164)Evelina
Italian · Fort Greene · $$
4.7(1,535)Isabelle's Osteria
Italian · Gramercy · $$
4.7(1,413)LaRina Pastificio & Vino
Italian · Fort Greene · $$
4.7(1,240)
Never miss a table in New York
WaitlistWizard tracks reservation availability at the hardest-to-book restaurants in real time. Set a watch on a sold-out table and get alerted the moment a spot opens up.
Frequently asked questions
- What are the best Italian restaurants in New York?
- Ranked by diner ratings across the 327 Italian restaurants in our New York catalog, the top picks are Osteria la Baia, Macoletta Brick Oven Pizzeria, and Osteria Carlina Tribeca.
- Which New York neighborhoods are best for Italian restaurants?
- West Village, Williamsburg, and Greenwich Village have the highest concentration of Italian restaurants in our New York catalog.
- How do I get a table at a fully booked restaurant in New York?
- WaitlistWizard monitors live reservation availability at 245 of these restaurants. Set a free watch on a sold-out table and you'll get an alert the moment a reservation opens up.